In this post, I’m going to review three different models of iPod Receivers, two by Denon and one by Marantz. Then I’m going to contrast them and then leave it up to you to decide which one is better. We’ll start with Denon.

Denon ASD-51W & ASD-51N Comparison

On the surface, both of Denon’s models, the ASD-51W and 51N appear very similar, with the notable exception of an exterior antenna on the 51 – evidence of its Wi-Fi capabilities. Each product features an assortment of connectivity options such as S-video input – allowing the user to post videos and photos onto their TV. Each of these models supports the entire iPod product line – click here for more information about the Denon Compatibility Matrix. Three of the most unique features are as follows:

• Streaming Internet services – Using an internet connection, each model not only supports subscription-based services such as Rhapsody and Napster, but also internet radio stations such as Pandora, Grooveshark and Ping.fm.
• Party Mode – the ability to broadcast simultaneously in up to five rooms.
• Wi-Fi capabilities in the 51W increase its portability, as well as its price.

Marantz IS301

When Marantz sat down to create the IS301, they wanted to answer one problem – how do you supplement the capabilities of the iPod with minimum impact on its functionality? What they created was a fully featured docking station that distinguishes itself from the competition through its portability, its navigation system and its unique TV interface.

The IS301 features a docking station that fits in the palm of your hand and allows you to stream both audio and video to any Bluetooth compatible receivers within 30 feet. Many docking stations anchor the iPod to a fixed location and allow mobility only through a remote control. Why sacrifice this mobility? The IS301 lets you charge your iPod as you walk, broadcasting to any Bluetooth receiver you choose – home theater, laptops, etc.

Another issue that the engineering team looked at was the navigation system. Many docking stations use a proprietary menu system that is often confusing and difficult to use. Marantz wanted to create a more intuitive menu, but at the same time remove the learning curve for new users. The answer seems deceptively simple – why not use the same interface as the iPod? Since the iPod already has a really cool interface, the IS301 lets you navigate their system just as you would without the dock.

Lastly, one of the major challenge users face with other docking stations is that they stream primarily through a TV – which must be on at the time to navigate the system. Because the IS301 uses the iPod’s native user interface, this is no longer an issue – users can navigate the system normally without relying on outside peripherals.

So which is better?

Well, that’s ultimately your call – it all depends on your connectivity needs. Are you looking to bring your music on the go, say, in your car? Well, considering that most cars don’t come equipped with a Wi-Fi Hotspot, you’re probably going to be using a Bluetooth connection. If that’s the case, you might want to consider Marantz. On the other hand, if you’re looking to entertain a house full of guests from a single stereo, you’ll probably be better off opting for the Wi-Fi connectivity in the Denon Doc.